Five Things You Need to Know about MAGA Republicans

A refresher on what motivates Trump’s MAGA Coalition – and the America they want

Donald Trump is now a convicted felon. This is an objectively good thing but you wouldn’t know it from a lot of the discourse in the media and online. Trump and his allies are attempting to claim that being a convicted felon only makes Trump stronger, and political pundits keep saying that a conviction wouldn’t impact the upcoming election. Even on the Left, there’s debate as to how Biden and Democrats should talk about Trump’s conviction. 

The conversation has been frustrating but I get it. At this point, most of us have internalized that Trump’s supporters will stick with him no matter what. That the media will continually grade Trump on a curve and give him a pass. That even when we beat Trump and MAGA it doesn’t feel like a win. In the face of all that, it’s hard not to feel discouraged. 

Here’s why I’m not: two years ago, it seemed impossible that Trump would ever be charged with a crime, much less be found guilty. Now, a jury has come back with a swift and unanimous verdict, convicting the first former president of the United States on all 34 charges. Multiple additional criminal cases in other jurisdictions continue, and Trump cronies have been charged in Arizona and Wisconsin for attempting to rig the 2020 election. Even in our flawed and weakened justice system, Trump and his fellow conspirators are being held accountable. That won’t sway his die-hard supporters, but I refuse to believe it won’t have an impact on voters come November, especially in an election where the outcome will likely come down to razor-thin margins.

This week I thought it would be helpful to offer a refresher on Trump’s MAGA Republicans and what they want. To understand this moment in America requires understanding what motivates Trump’s supporters. Not because we can’t beat them (as a reminder MAGA has lost every election cycle since 2016), but because beating them requires understanding the battle we’re actually fighting. Here’s what you need to know:

MAGA Republicans don’t believe in laws or norms. Only using them to their advantage. Trump and his cronies openly fantasize about everyone they’ll investigate and prosecute if Trump wins in November. The list includes District Attorney Alvin Bragg, Judge Merchan, Joe Biden, and even Barack Obama. The last two are comical since Trump has also argued that former presidents should have total immunity, but that’s the point. Donald Trump and the people who support them believe that might makes right. Laws and norms are meant to keep their opponents in line, not be applied to them. They don’t care about hypocrisy. They don’t care about anything but winning and punishing anyone who attempts to stop them. 

MAGA Republicans gain power and immediately put it to use. Elected Republicans across the US are passing voter suppression legislation, making abortion illegal in multiple states, and coming for birth control next. They’re taking away the right to protest, and the rights of LGBTQ+ Americans. They’re banning Black History from being taught in schools and attempting to gut public education overall. As the Texas GOP platform shows, they have still more horrors planned. It’s worth noting that these electeds are counting on six MAGA Supreme Court Justices, who are essentially unelected political operatives, to let them get away with it. And I’ve already written a whole post on how these Justices flaunt their own power and make clear to America that they don’t believe anyone can hold them accountable either.

MAGA Republicans understand the importance of media and cultural power. We see the same attempts to consolidate power and control the flow of information and rhetoric in media and tech. Elon now owns Twitter, Trump wannabe Vivek Ramaswamy is making a play for Buzzfeed, and multiple Silicon Valley players are all in for Trump’s reelection campaign. Meanwhile, on the culture front, Chris Rufo continues his crusade to purge academic, news, and cultural institutions of any ideas or people he doesn’t like. The MAGA Right is also the fuel for every current backlash and moral panic you can think of.

MAGA Republicans plan to win by any means necessary. Trump isn’t trying to win an election. He and his MAGAites just see it as the next opportunity to take back control. Should they lose again, they’ll simply look for other avenues to seize it. The January 6 insurrection was a major setback for MAGA, but the movement has been working overtime ever since to gaslight Americans on what happened and turn the insurrectionists into folk heroes. They’ve also been hard at work attempting to dismantle everything that stopped them from holding onto power after the 2020 election loss. Trump and MAGA will continue to spread conspiracies, incite violence against opponents, and dehumanize marginalized communities in service of gaining power and control.

MAGA Republicans thrive on our misery and use it strategically. This is a movement built on slogans like “liberal tears,” “cry harder,” and “facts don’t care about your feelings.” It’s not enough to win, Trump and MAGA Republicans want to punish their opponents and see us suffer. The Atlantic’s Tom Nichols captures it best, “The Republican base actively embraces Trump’s grievances; it emulates his pettiness; it supports his childlike inability to accept responsibility. These voters are not sighing in resignation and voting for the lesser of two or three or four evils. They are getting what they want—because they, too, are set on revenge.”

But there’s also a strategy here. If done well, it can suppress votes. Something that arguably worked in 2016. It’s worth remembering that the same political operatives and media outlets that spent all of 2022 telling you that voters don't care about abortion will spend the rest of 2024 assuring you that Trump's now being a convicted felon doesn't matter either. MAGA Republicans want the majority of Americans to believe the election doesn’t matter and stay home on election day. For the lolz but ultimately for the win.

We’ve beaten them multiple times now and I believe we can beat them again come November.

But we need to be clear-eyed about what the true aims of MAGA Republicans are and how far they’re willing to go. Right now, I think it’s especially important to understand and internalize that they want us demoralized and why. It’s a helpful reminder, especially in a year of one brutal news cycle after another about the election.

Trump’s conviction matters. Early polling indicates it will hurt his candidacy. Most Americans don’t want a convicted felon as President and they don’t want the future that MAGA envisions. We have less than five months to make sure all of these charges, convictions, and accountability matter. 

Enjoying Ctrl Alt-Right Delete? Become a paid subscriber. The newsletter will always be free, but subscribers will receive a bonus edition with additional ICYMI links and, on occasion, short posts. 

---

ICYMI

Another Pride, Another Boycott: Right-wing Media Attempt to Cancel Children’s Educator Ms Rachel (Media Matters)

Ms. Rachel is a modern-day Mr. Rogers and a savior for many a parent of babies and toddlers. She’s racked up billions of YouTube views and parents trust her like no other children’s entertainer (Including this parent. I adore Ms. Rachel!) So of course MAGA is harassing her and calling on a boycott to build their own clout and make a buck. The sad thing is that as soon as my kids started watching her, all I could think about was the inevitable harassment she and her cast of characters (including a singer who identifies as nonbinary) would eventually endure. 

How Q Became Everything (Mother Jones)

Ali Breland’s final piece for Mother Jones is a worthy read. QAnon as a brand might be dead, but QAnon conspiracies and harassment live on as mainstream political rhetoric. It’s become a long-running, completely unfounded moral panic.

Texas Professors Sue to Fail Students Who Seek Abortions (Salon)

Remember when anti-choicers pretended their actual goal was to protect women? It turns out that was bullshit and the anti-choice movement was all about controlling women and punishing them. As this insane lawsuit shows. 

DOJ Says Epoch Times Newspaper Is an Epic Money-Laundering Operation (New Yorker)

The Epoch Times, and its influence over MAGA America, is continually fascinating to me. I’ve been obsessed ever since NBC News reporter Brandy Zadrozny started writing about them in 2019. We’ll surely learn even more through these criminal proceedings.  

---

Coda

Announcement: I’ve added a paid membership option to CARD. The newsletter will always be free, but subscribers will receive a bonus edition with ICYMI links and occasional short original content. Contributions will go directly to me, allowing me to spend more time crafting newsletter content each week.

You can subscribe here: 

If you want an alternative (a non-Substack) means of support, you can donate via my Patreon and receive the same benefits.

I have mixed feelings about doing this and have avoided it for a while. Substack's track record on hate speech is abysmal, and it's clear that the platform has no interest in addressing the problem. But the same is true of several tech companies where I still have accounts, including Twitter and Meta. Continuing to offer both Patreon and Substack as options is a compromise that I can live with. 

Thanks so much for supporting Ctrl Alt Right Delete and continuing to read each week. I keep doing this because you keep letting me know it matters. 

Apologies that there was no newsletter last week. My family had a medical emergency, but I’m pleased to report everyone is doing OK. I’ll see you again next Sunday!